A Utah judge fines BYU's outside lawyers $3,000 over AI-hallucinated briefs
One lawyer said he drafted with four AI tools and never checked the output. The other didn't review the filings at all.
By industry
What legal owners and operators have put into production, what it cost and what went wrong.
One lawyer said he drafted with four AI tools and never checked the output. The other didn't review the filings at all.
Garfield AI did the paperwork; a human barrister argued the case. The firm says the client paid about £400 in fees.
AVA answers questions about settling an estate. Its builders cut their test set from 91 questions to 16 and scaled back the goal of replicating a human helper.
The Fifth Circuit found 16 fabricated quotations in a reply brief. It said the sanction would likely have been lower if the lawyer had owned up.
DoNotPay sold a subscription it called "the world's first robot lawyer." The FTC says the company never checked whether it worked like one, and has now finalized an order that bans the claim without evidence.
Collection: Legal AI use cases → Planned